9 Comments
founding
Aug 25Liked by Douglas Burns

I have no idea if this is true or not, but I can believe that Mawmaw would use those words and that kind of phrasing when talking to her grandson. For heaven's sake she set Pawpaw on fire while he slept one night 😳. Talk about weird.

Expand full comment
Aug 25Liked by Douglas Burns

Thank you for dissecting this “reality” so clearly and candidly. My experience tells me you are right on target for calling his story for what it is!!

Expand full comment
Aug 24Liked by Douglas Burns

The question is, is Burns in a position to say, definitively, that the story is false?

No, he isn't.

Expand full comment

No, it doesn't ring true. Regardless, I suspect that he would write a totally different book today now he's MAGA, and that he would leave that part out, or find someone, perhaps a teacher or librarian to blame for those feelings.

Expand full comment

Great unpacking of a very strange story. Thanks.

Expand full comment

Your last paragraph is a work of art that neatly sums up the whole of Vance as far as I can tell.

Expand full comment

I have not read Hillbilly Elegy nor do I intend to. I appreciate your comments that validate my choice to ignore it, as I also try ignore him and his running mate.

Expand full comment

with the political leanings of iowa and south dakota i'm truly fearful that we're all being pulled into the eternal fires of maga...

Expand full comment

From listening to Vance, his rhetoric bears little credibility so why would his book differ. Doug, your writing has more substance and eloquence than anything Vance could pen.

Expand full comment